Here are Dan and Cat’s rankings for the movies we’ve watched so far (along with the listener rankings – a combination of the podcast episodes that have attracted the most listens and social media polls):

RankingCatDanPodcast Listeners
1North By NorthwestPsychoRear Window
2NotoriousThe BirdsSabotage
3SabotageDial M For MurderVertigo
4The BirdsNorth By NorthwestPsycho
5PsychoSabotageNorth By Northwest
6Strangers on a TrainForeign CorrespondentNotorious
7Stage FrightStrangers on a TrainShadow of a Doubt
8Dial M For MurderVertigoStrangers on a Train
9Foreign CorrespondentNotoriousThe Birds
10SaboteurStage FrightFrenzy
11Number 17FrenzyRebecca
12VertigoTopazThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)
13Rear WindowRebeccaThe Trouble With Harry
14Shadow of a DoubtRear WindowStage Fright
16RebeccaSaboteurForeign Correspondent
17LifeboatShadow of a DoubtSecret Agent
18Rich and StrangeSuspicionRich and Strange
21SpellboundThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)Spellbound
22The Trouble With HarryLifeboatDial M For Murder
23The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)Secret AgentBlackmail 
24Secret AgentThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Easy Virtue
25The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Number 17Marnie
26The LodgerThe LodgerSuspicion
27ChampagneRich and StrangeJuno and the Paycock
28FrenzyThe Paradine CaseChampagne
29The Paradine CaseMurder!The Wrong Man
30The Wrong ManThe Skin GameThe Lodger
31MarnieBlackmailThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)
32Juno and the PaycockFamily PlotMurder!
33The Skin GameThe Trouble With HarryNumber 17
34Easy VirtueThe Wrong ManThe Paradine Case
35SuspicionEasy VirtueThe Skin Game
36Family PlotJuno and the PaycockFamily Plot