Here are Dan and Cat’s rankings for the movies we’ve watched so far (along with the listener rankings – a combination of the podcast episodes that have attracted the most listens and social media polls):

RankingCatDanPodcast Listeners
1North By NorthwestRopeRear Window
2The Lady VanishesPsychoNorth By Northwest
3NotoriousThe BirdsVertigo
4The 39 StepsTo Catch A ThiefPsycho
5SabotageDial M For MurderStrangers on a Train
6The BirdsNorth By NorthwestShadow of a Doubt
7PsychoThe Lady VanishesNotorious
8Strangers on a TrainSabotageThe 39 Steps
9Stage FrightForeign CorrespondentDial M For Murder
10To Catch A ThiefStrangers on a TrainRope
11Young and InnocentVertigoThe Birds
12Dial M For MurderNotoriousThe Lady Vanishes
13I ConfessStage FrightSabotage
14Foreign CorrespondentThe 39 StepsTo Catch A Thief
15SaboteurI ConfessThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)
16Number 17Torn CurtainFrenzy
17VertigoFrenzyTorn Curtain
18Rear WindowTopazRebecca
19Shadow of a DoubtRebeccaStage Fright
20TopazRear WindowYoung and Innocent
21RopeSpellboundI Confess
22RebeccaYoung and InnocentThe Trouble With Harry
24The Pleasure GardenShadow of a DoubtSecret Agent
25Rich and StrangeSuspicionThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)
26Murder!The Pleasure GardenThe Wrong Man
27BlackmailThe ManxmanSpellbound
28SpellboundJamaica InnThe Paradine Case
29 The Trouble With HarryChampagneForeign Correspondent
30Waltzes From ViennaMarnieJamaica Inn
31 The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)Easy Virtue
32Secret AgentLifeboatSuspicion
33The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Secret AgentTopaz
34The LodgerThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Rich and Strange
35The Farmer’s WifeNumber 17Blackmail
36The ManxmanThe LodgerThe Pleasure Garden
37ChampagneThe Farmer’s WifeMarnie
38The RingWaltzes From ViennaMurder!
39Torn CurtainRich and StrangeSaboteur
40FrenzyThe Paradine CaseMr and Mrs Smith
41The Paradine CaseMurder!Family Plot
42Jamaica InnBlackmailUnder Capricorn
43The Wrong ManDownhillThe Farmer’s Wife
44MarnieThe Skin GameThe Lodger
45Under CapricornFamily PlotChampagne
46DownhillThe Trouble With HarryWaltzes From Vienna
47Juno and the PaycockThe RingThe Ring
48The Skin GameUnder CapricornDownhill
49Easy VirtueThe Wrong ManNumber 17
50SuspicionMr and Mrs SmithThe Manxman
51Family PlotEasy VirtueJuno and the Paycock
52Mr and Mrs SmithJuno and the PaycockThe Skin Game

Note: Bon Voyage and Aventure Malgache are not included in these rankings, since they’re far shorter and not directly comparable. After watching Bon Voyage, however, both Dan and Cat gave it a hearty ‘thumbs up’. Aventure Malgache? Not so much. A dual thumbs down.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial