Here are Dan and Cat’s rankings for the movies we’ve watched so far (along with the listener rankings – a combination of the podcast episodes that have attracted the most listens and social media polls):

RankingCatDanPodcast Listeners
1North By NorthwestRopeRear Window
2NotoriousPsychoNorth By Northwest
3The 39 StepsThe BirdsVertigo
4SabotageDial M For MurderPsycho
5The BirdsNorth By NorthwestStrangers on a Train
6PsychoSabotageShadow of a Doubt
7Strangers on a TrainForeign CorrespondentNotorious
8Stage FrightStrangers on a TrainThe 39 Steps
9Dial M For MurderVertigoDial M For Murder
10I ConfessNotoriousThe Birds
11Foreign CorrespondentStage FrightRope
12SaboteurThe 39 StepsSabotage
13Number 17I ConfessThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)
14VertigoTorn CurtainFrenzy
15Rear WindowFrenzyTorn Curtain
16Shadow of a DoubtTopazRebecca
17TopazRebeccaStage Fright
18RopeRear WindowI Confess
19RebeccaSpellboundThe Trouble With Harry
21Rich and StrangeShadow of a DoubtSecret Agent
22Murder!SuspicionThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)
23BlackmailThe ManxmanThe Wrong Man
24SpellboundJamaica InnSpellbound
25 The Trouble With HarryChampagneThe Paradine Case
26Waltzes From ViennaMarnieForeign Correspondent
27 The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)Jamaica Inn
28Secret AgentLifeboatEasy Virtue
29The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Secret AgentSuspicion
30 The LodgerThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Topaz
31The ManxmanNumber 17Rich and Strange
32ChampagneThe LodgerBlackmail
33Torn CurtainWaltzes From ViennaMarnie
34FrenzyRich and StrangeMurder!
35The Paradine CaseThe Paradine CaseSaboteur
36Jamaica InnMurder!Mr and Mrs Smith
37The Wrong ManThe Skin GameFamily Plot
38MarnieBlackmailUnder Capricorn
39Under CapricornFamily PlotThe Lodger
40Juno and the PaycockThe Trouble With HarryChampagne
41The Skin GameUnder CapricornWaltzes From Vienna
42Easy VirtueThe Wrong ManNumber 17
43SuspicionMr and Mrs SmithThe Manxman
44Family PlotEasy VirtueJuno and the Paycock
45Mr and Mrs SmithJuno and the PaycockThe Skin Game

Note: Bon Voyage and Aventure Malgache are not included in these rankings, since they’re far shorter and not directly comparable. After watching Bon Voyage, however, both Dan and Cat gave it a hearty ‘thumbs up’.