Here are Dan and Cat’s rankings for the movies we’ve watched so far (along with the listener rankings – a combination of the podcast episodes that have attracted the most listens and social media polls):

RankingCatDanPodcast Listeners
1North By NorthwestRopeRear Window
2NotoriousPsychoNorth By Northwest
3SabotageThe BirdsVertigo
4The BirdsDial M For MurderPsycho
5PsychoNorth By NorthwestStrangers on a Train
6Strangers on a TrainSabotageShadow of a Doubt
7Stage FrightForeign CorrespondentNotorious
8Dial M For MurderStrangers on a TrainDial M For Murder
9I ConfessVertigoRope
10Foreign CorrespondentNotoriousThe Birds
11SaboteurStage FrightSabotage
12Number 17I ConfessThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)
13VertigoTorn CurtainFrenzy
14Rear WindowFrenzyTorn Curtain
15Shadow of a DoubtTopazRebecca
16TopazRebeccaI Confess
17RopeRear WindowStage Fright
18RebeccaSpellboundThe Trouble With Harry
19LifeboatSaboteurSecret Agent
20Rich and StrangeShadow of a DoubtLifeboat
21Murder!SuspicionThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)
22BlackmailJamaica InnThe Wrong Man
24The Trouble With HarryMarnieThe Paradine Case
25Waltzes From ViennaThe Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)Foreign Correspondent
26The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)LifeboatJamaica Inn
27Secret AgentSecret AgentEasy Virtue
28The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)Suspicion
29The LodgerNumber 17Topaz
30ChampagneThe LodgerRich and Strange
31Torn CurtainWaltzes From ViennaBlackmail
32FrenzyRich and StrangeMarnie
33The Paradine CaseThe Paradine CaseMurder!
34Jamaica InnMurder!Saboteur
35The Wrong ManThe Skin GameFamily Plot
36MarnieBlackmailMr and Mrs Smith
37Under CapricornFamily PlotChampagne
38Juno and the PaycockThe Trouble With HarryWaltzes From Vienna
39The Skin GameUnder CapricornUnder Capricorn
40Easy VirtueThe Wrong ManThe Lodger
41SuspicionMr and Mrs SmithNumber 17
42Family PlotEasy VirtueJuno and the Paycock
43Mr and Mrs SmithJuno and the PaycockThe Skin Game

Note: Bon Voyage and Aventure Malgache are not included in these rankings, since they’re far shorter and not directly comparable. After watching Bon Voyage, however, both Dan and Cat gave it a hearty ‘thumbs up’.